The Madras High Court has granted anticipatory bail to a
woman facing charges of bigamy, holding that under Section 82 of the Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita a person who is herself unmarried and marries a man without
knowledge of his existing marriage does not become an offender. The Court
clarified that the provision targets only the individual who already has a
living spouse and contracts a second marriage during its subsistence. The
petitioner, arrayed as an accused, approached the High Court under Section 482 of
the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita seeking anticipatory bail in a case
registered at the All-Women Police Station. Justice N. Ramesh observed that
Section 82 substantially reproduces the earlier Sections 494 and 495 of the
Indian Penal Code. Sub-section (1) punishes a person who, having a spouse
living, marries again, while sub-section (2) enhances the punishment where the
fact of the former marriage is concealed from the subsequent partner. On a
plain reading of the provision, the offender is the person who already has a
living spouse; an unmarried woman who enters into marriage without knowledge of
that subsisting union does not thereby attract liability under Section 82.
According to the factual background, the de facto
complainant, the first wife of the principal accused, alleged that the
petitioner had entered into a marriage with him. The petitioner maintained that
she had no knowledge, at the time of the marriage, that the man already had a
subsisting marriage with the complainant, and that this fact had been
deliberately concealed from her. She asserted that she was herself a victim of
deception rather than a participant in any offence. The FIR invoked Sections
82, 85, 49, 296(b) and 351(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
In its reasoning the Court explained that Section 82(1) is
directed exclusively at the person who marries again while a spouse is living.
Reliance was placed on the Karnataka High Court’s decision in Thimmappa v.
Bharathi, which held that only the spouse who contracts a second marriage
during the subsistence of the earlier one can be prosecuted under the
corresponding provision of the Indian Penal Code, and that relatives or the
second spouse cannot be roped in without material demonstrating knowledge and participation.
Addressing the petitioner’s specific plea of want of knowledge, the Bench noted
that the truth of that plea is a matter for investigation and, if necessary, trial.
For the limited purpose of anticipatory bail, however, and in the absence of
any material placed by the prosecution to show that the petitioner was aware of
the subsisting marriage, the case against her under Section 82 did not disclose
the gravity that would justify custodial interrogation.
The Court also examined the charge under Section 85 of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, which corresponds to the earlier Section 498-A of the
Indian Penal Code and punishes cruelty inflicted on a woman by her husband or a
relative of the husband. If the petitioner’s alliance with the principal
accused was, as she claimed, one she entered into believing herself to be his
wife while in fact being deceived as to the subsistence of his earlier
marriage, she did not thereby become a relative of the husband of the de facto
complainant. On the petitioner’s case, she and the complainant occupied the
position of two women deceived and wronged by the same man, not that of an
accused and her victim. The core allegation under Section 82 was, on the
statutory language and the authorities, directed at the person who already had
a subsisting marriage, namely the principal accused, and not at the petitioner.
The allegation under Section 85 was likewise not, prima facie, sustainable
against her.
Taking into account that the petitioner was a woman who had
approached the Court promptly and that the charges against her lacked the
requisite foundation at the present stage, the Bench allowed the application.
She was ordered to be released on bail in the event of arrest or on her
appearance before the Magistrate, subject to the execution of a bond for a sum
of Rs 25,000 with two sureties of like amount to the satisfaction of the
concerned Magistrate.