The Supreme Court has dismissed 271 civil appeals and
special leave petitions filed by the Union of India concerning disability
pension claims of ex-servicemen, observing that the 2015 Raksha Mantri
Committee’s recommendation for the immediate withdrawal of pending litigation
involving disabilities classified as “Neither Attributable Nor Aggravated”
(NANA) had not been faithfully implemented. The Court noted that the Ministry
of Defence had formally accepted the recommendation in 2018, yet appeals of the
same nature continued to be pursued. The Bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam
Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe also examined whether the Entitlement
Rules for Casualty Pensionary Awards, 2008 materially altered the beneficial
framework under the Entitlement Rules, 1982.
The disputes arose from cases where Release Medical Boards
had initially assessed the disabilities of ex-servicemen as NANA. Based on
those assessments, departmental appeals filed by the affected personnel were
rejected. The ex-servicemen subsequently approached the Armed Forces Tribunal
or the jurisdictional High Courts, which interfered with the departmental
decisions and granted disability pension after finding that the disabilities
were attributable to or aggravated by military service. The Union challenged
these orders before the Supreme Court. The Court observed that the present
batch represented only a small portion of similar matters previously dealt with
by it, including cases dismissed on grounds of delay and on merits.
While considering the legal framework, the Court traced the
development of disability pension provisions from the Pension Regulations of
1940 through the Entitlement Rules, 1982, and examined the principles laid down
in Dharamvir Singh v. Union of India (2013). It also considered the controversy
surrounding the promulgation of the 2008 Rules, including the 2015 Raksha
Mantri Committee’s observation regarding the absence of approval from the
Cabinet and the Department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare. Without
conclusively deciding the validity of their promulgation, the Court proceeded
on the assumption that the 2008 Rules were legally operative and examined
whether they substantially changed the existing entitlement framework.
The Court undertook a rule-by-rule comparison concerning
presumption at entry into service, causal connection, burden of proof,
aggravation and disabilities whose causes were unknown. It concluded that the
2008 Rules did not fundamentally depart from the protective framework of the
1982 Rules. Although the 2008 Rules modified the presumption concerning a
serviceman’s health at the time of entry, the basic principle that the
Department bears the primary burden of establishing that a disability is
neither attributable to nor aggravated by service remained intact. The Court
identified only a limited exception under Rule 7 for claims raised more than
fifteen years after discharge, retirement, invalidment or release.
The Court emphasised that the mere manifestation of a
disease during military service does not automatically establish attribution or
aggravation. Claims must be assessed individually, taking into account the
nature of the disease, service conditions, clinical and service history, and
the existence of a causal relationship with military service. Medical Board
opinions must receive due consideration, while Tribunals are required to
scrutinise such opinions carefully before deciding pending claims.
The Court also referred to data obtained under the Right to
Information Act indicating that only 142 out of 2,997 claims considered by the
First Appellate Authority had been accepted. It stressed the importance of
transparency and clarity in the rules governing pensionary benefits so that
ex-servicemen have confidence in the manner in which their claims are assessed.
The appeals were ultimately dismissed both on the ground of delay and on
merits, with the Court leaving no order as to costs.