The Supreme Court on Monday dismissed a set of pleas
challenging the Bombay High Court’s decision to set aside the bail earlier
granted to three accused in connection with the devastating 2025 Goa nightclub
fire that claimed twenty-five lives. A bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta
and Sheel Nagu directed the nightclub owners Saurav Luthra and Gaurav Luthra,
along with their business partner Ajay Gupta, to surrender before the concerned
court within two weeks. The apex court further directed the trial court to
expedite the proceedings so that the case could progress without unnecessary
delay.
The tragedy occurred on the night of December 6, 2025, when
a massive fire engulfed the Birch by Romeo Lane nightclub located in Arpora,
North Goa. The blaze left twenty-five people dead and approximately fifty
others injured, triggering widespread public outrage and intensive police
investigation into alleged safety lapses and regulatory violations at the
establishment.
Earlier, on August 18, the Bombay High Court had cancelled
the bail granted to the three accused by the trial court. The High Court
observed that the sessions court had failed to properly evaluate the material
collected during the investigation and had erred in characterising the offence
as less heinous than crimes such as murder or dacoity. According to the High
Court, the material on record clearly indicated that the restaurant was
operating without the required licences and that its structure itself was unauthorised.
The court further noted that the accused and their partners were allegedly
aware of the serious risks involved in conducting fire displays inside the
premises without adequate safety measures in place.
The Luthra brothers and Ajay Gupta were partners in M/s
Being GS Hospitality Arpora LLP, the firm that operated the nightclub. The
trial court had granted them bail in April this year. While cancelling that
relief, the High Court had specifically directed the three accused to surrender
before the sessions court within a period of two weeks. The Goa government had
approached the High Court challenging the sessions court’s order that had
enlarged the trio on bail.
In refusing to interfere with the High Court’s order, the
Supreme Court effectively affirmed the view that the gravity of the allegations
and the material placed on record justified the cancellation of bail. By
directing the accused to surrender within the stipulated time and by calling
upon the trial court to accelerate the process, the apex court signalled the
need for prompt and focused adjudication of a case that involves significant
loss of life and serious questions of public safety and regulatory compliance.
The developments mark an important stage in the legal
proceedings arising from one of the most tragic incidents in Goa’s recent
history. With the Supreme Court declining to grant any further relief, the
three accused are now required to surrender as directed, while the trial court
has been asked to ensure that the matter moves forward expeditiously towards
framing of charges and eventual trial.